2026 Nov 20, Planetarium Educators Workshop: Questioning Strategies. Goals: introduce a scheme for classifying questions, to practice identifying types of questions, think of how to design intriguing sequences of questions. The right questions can help increase the value of our dialog with audiences. This is Part 5 in the Planetarium Educators Workshop series that began in July 2025 and is derived from the Planetarium Educators Workshop Guide. Workshop facilitator: Alan Gould <agould@berkeley.edu>.
Workshop slides are available at
https://docs.google.com/presentation/d/1rxtvUL7zA1a2B10Rr0msEqhYdzMM8VSsuO8QnJbaZDs/edit?usp=drive_link
Mary Holt, Longway Planetarium Flint Michigan
Alan Gould, Berkeley California USA
Jeff Nee at Sky-Skan
Lesley Simanton-Coogan, Coleman Planetarium in Dahlonega, GA (USA)
Todd Ullery - SSA: Hello, Todd Ullery from York, PA
Maria Mutz, from the University of Arizona in Tucson, AZ
Karl von Ahnen, Santa Cruz Mountains, California
Josh Elder - Merrillville, Indiana - Gregg L. Williams Planetarium
Mikko Suominen, Ivalo, Finland (in Lapland, 68.7 degrees North)
Krista Testin, Mallory Kountze Planetarium in Omaha, NE, USA
Rosemary Walling, Juneau Alaska
Alyssa
Maria Mutz
[Ideas for categorizing questions]
1. What does a light-year measure?
Todd: information,
Jeff Nee: closed question,
Rosemary: recall,
Krista: elicit response,
Lesley: a specific fact,
Karl: Recalling,
Alyssa: closed
2. What topics would you like me to cover in our next planetarium show?
Todd: open ended,
Alyssa: Interest/Opinion,
Rosemary: ideas,
Maria Mutz: both are open but one has right/wrong answers, the second doesn’t,
Rosemary: grab interest,
Lesley: getting feedback
3. Did you hear my last question?
Alyssa: Closed question (yes or no),
Karl: reacting, Lesley -paying attention,
Todd: checking attention of audience
4. Based on your observations of the setting sun during the last two weeks, where do you predict it will set one week from now?
Lesley: prediction
Karl: inductive and deductive reasoning
Krista Testin: Reacted to "inductive and deductive reasoning" with 👍
Rosemary Walling: Speculating
5. What do you think your life would be like if you were an astronomer?
Lesley Simanton-Coogan: imagining
Karl von Ahnen: speculating
Alyssa: Inquiry
Jeff Nee: lead to fresh ideas
jelder: #4 is Application
Rosemary Walling: grab interest
Alyssa: leading
6. Planets certainly aren’t as hot as stars, are they?
Lesley Simanton-Coogan: leading
Jeff Nee: It's not really a question at all, is it?
Mary Holt (She/Her) - Longway Planetarium, Flint MI: Leading
Krista Testin: Reacted to "Leading" with 👍
Karl von Ahnen: lead to fresh ideas
00:47:01 Mary Holt: You do have to be careful with humor though, not all jokes are appropriate for work/planetarium settings
Examples of synthesizing questions (from participants)
Jeff Nee: Where do you think the Moon will be in a few days?
Lesley Simanton-Coogan: If the sun is setting and the moon is rising, what phase is it?
Todd Ullery : Use the Two Small Piece of Glass candle example for star temperature and color
Alyssa: Why do you think the larger planets in our solar system currently have rings?
Rosemary Walling: Will Mars and Jupiter be as close to each other in a month?
Karl von Ahnen: Why do planets sometimes seem to move “backwards”?
Examples of Open-ended questions (from participants)
Krista Testin: What was your favorite part and why?
Mary Holt: What do these stars look like to you?
Jeff Nee: How would you describe what you're seeing now?
Rosemary Walling: Why invest in Moon exploration?
Mikko Suominen: Where on Mars would you like to travel to, if you could choose?
Alyssa: Why do you think humans are so fascinated by space?
Lesley Simanton-Coogan: What do you think it would be like to be an astronaut?
Mary Holt: And my answer is, absolutely I would not, lol; Lesley reacted 👍 Jeff reacted 👍
Alyssa: Can an open-ended question also be a feeling question?
Examples of Managerial questions (from participants)
Jeff Nee: Who would like to volunteer to help me with this demo?
Rosemary Walling: Can you see the Earth - to make sure people lying on the floor can see
Karl von Ahnen: Does everyone see the pointer? (Moving slowly overhead)
01:03:32 Rosemary Walling: Rhetorical
01:03:57 Rosemary Walling: Direct Information
[Types of questions: Direct Information, Synthesizing, Open-ended, Feeling, Managerial, Rhetorical
01:30:21 Rosemary Walling: [references regarding wait time:] * "Wait Time in College Science Classes" by George Moriber (Science Education, 1971 , vol. 55, no. 3, pp. 321-328) and "Science, Silence, and Sanctions" by Mary Budd Rowe (Science and Children, March, 1969, pp. 11-13).
01:39:24 Alan Gould: Alan Gould <agould@berkeley.edu>
[Last slide URLs and contact email]
Planetarium Activities for Successful Shows (PASS)
Volume 1: Planetarium Educators’ Workshop Guide
www.ips-planetarium.org/page/pass or gss.lawrencehallofscience.org/planetariums
Rosemary: Seminar Recordings - https://www.ppadomes.org/ https://www.youtube.com/@ppadomes/videos
This Summary was zoom-AI-generated and human-edited by Alan Gould.
This was Module 5 of the Planetarium Educators Workshop series, focused on questioning strategies for planetarium presenters.
The session introduced a classification framework for question types: Direct Information, Synthesizing, Open-Ended, Feeling, Managerial, and Rhetorical.
Participants practiced categorizing questions from a real planetarium program and discussed how to improve question sequences.
Key themes included wait time, creating a safe space for audience participation, pair sharing, and how tone of voice affects question delivery.
Recording and analyzing one's own presentations was discussed as a powerful self-improvement strategy.
The next module (Module 6) on designing audience participation activities is planned for 2027.
Rosemary introduced Alan and provided context for the workshop series. Alan introduced the session as Module 5 of the Planetarium Educators Workshop series, derived from the Planetarium Educators Workshop Guide (IPS Special Publication No. 10), originally developed by Alan Friedman and colleagues starting in 1979.
Host, Rosemary: Introduced Alan as a Fellow of the International Planetarium Society (IPS), 2024 IPS Service Award recipient, member of the IPS Education Committee, former PPA Treasurer, and Director Emeritus of the Lawrence Hall of Science Planetarium. She announced the next seminar featuring Kate Troesch from the Astro Society on "Night Sky Network Connecting Communities," scheduled for the second Friday of next month at 2 PM Pacific / 5 PM Eastern / 22 UTC.
Alan: Summarized prior modules — Module 1 (Communication), Module 2 (Subject, Presenter, Audience), Module 3 (Organizational Patterns), Module 4 (How Students Perceive Programs). All prior modules are recorded and available on the website seminar archive and YouTube page. Module 5 focuses on questioning strategies to foster audience dialogue.
Alan presented six example questions and invited participants to categorize them in the chat, generating an organic discussion of question types before introducing a formal framework.
Alan: Asked participants to classify questions such as "What does a light year measure?", "What topics would you like me to cover?", "Did you hear my last question?", "Based on your observations of the setting sun, where do you predict it will set?", "What do you think your life would be like if you were an astronomer?", and "Planets certainly aren't as hot as stars, are they?"
Participants contributed categories including: information, closed, recall, open-ended, opinion, prediction, synthesizing, inductive/deductive reasoning, speculation, imagining, and rhetorical. [See Chat for all contributions freom participants.]
Maria Noted that both the first and second questions are open, but one has right and wrong answers.
Questions can often belong to multiple categories simultaneously.
Tone and emphasis when asking a question significantly affect its impact and the type of response it elicits.
Alan introduced a classification scheme developed by Lawrence Lowry (education professor at UC Berkeley), which was used at the Lawrence Hall of Science Planetarium. The five types are: Direct Information, Synthesizing, Open-Ended, Feeling, Managerial, and Rhetorical.
Alan: Explained that research from 1967 found most planetarium instructor questions required only direct information — a finding likely still relevant today.
Direct Information questions recall facts or define terms; useful for ice-breaking and setting the stage at the start of a program.
Synthesizing questions involve comparison, contrast, association, classification, and relationships (e.g., "Based on your observations of the setting sun, where do you predict it will set?").
Open-Ended questions allow free exploration with minimal guidance (e.g., "What topics would you like me to cover?", "Are there places other than Earth that could have life?").
Feeling questions elicit emotional responses (e.g., "How did you feel when you first looked at the rings of Saturn through a telescope?").
Managerial questions manage the flow of the program (e.g., "Can everyone hear that?", "Is there anyone who has not yet received a star map?").
Rhetorical questions reinforce statements without expecting an answer (e.g., "Planets certainly aren't as hot as stars, are they?").
Jeff: Shared his practice of converting direct information questions into synthesizing questions so the audience can figure out answers themselves.
Alan: Suggested asking "How do you feel now that it's dark in the planetarium?" as a feeling question to gauge comfort, especially with young children.
Lesley: Described always warning audiences before dimming lights to reduce anxiety.
Karl: Shared a technique of having young children pretend to flip an imaginary switch on their chair arm to "turn on the stars," then immediately singing Twinkle Twinkle Little Star to ease the transition to darkness.
Lesley: Noted that some questions feel more broad and open-ended even when categorized as synthesizing, depending on context.
Alan: No single categorization is definitive; questions can span multiple types.
Participants were invited to contribute their own examples of synthesizing, open-ended, and feeling questions via chat and by unmuting.
Jeff: Suggested "Where do you think the moon will be in a few days?" (synthesizing) and advocated for describing observations aloud or sharing with a neighbor (pair-share) as an engagement strategy.
Lesley: Suggested "If the sun is setting and the moon is rising, what phase is it?" (synthesizing) and "Have you been to space, or would you go to space?" (feeling).
Todd Ullery: Referenced a "Two Pieces of Glass" (plnaetarium show) candle demonstration for star temperature and color as a synthesizing context.
Jeff: Noted that space can be both exciting and terrifying, and that astronaut application openings made him reconsider his own desire to go to space now that he has children.
Participants generated a rich variety of question examples across all categories.
Feeling questions are particularly effective for connecting audiences emotionally to astronomical topics.
Alan walked participants through ten questions from an actual planetarium program, asking the group to classify each and then suggest improvements.
Alan: Questions ranged from "Can anyone recognize the Big Dipper?" (direct information / yes-no) to managerial, open-ended, synthesizing, and feeling questions.
The instructor's response to a wrong answer ("You've got the right idea, but the wrong star") demonstrates the importance of how incorrect answers are handled.
Jeff: Suggested giving more wait time before accepting the first answer, not stopping at the first correct response, and framing the space as safe for all participants.
Mary: Suggested asking the whole group to point simultaneously to the Big Dipper so collective action helps individuals self-correct.
Karl: Noted that people often see "dippers" in multiple places (e.g., the Pleiades) and suggested eliciting more reasons why ancient civilizations created constellations.
Alan: Big Dipper, Little Dipper, and "Tiny Dipper."
Lesley: Described using questions as an invitation for internal reflection, encouraging every audience member to think of an answer rather than waiting for bold volunteers.
Jeff: Advocated strongly for pair-sharing as a scalable strategy across all age groups and dome sizes, noting it takes longer but opens participation beyond the few who always answer.
Alan: Reflected on the value of building in a submission delay in chat-based settings so all participants think before responding. E.g. "Please write your answer in the chat, but do not submit it (click return) until I say to do so."
Conclusions
The sequence of questions in a program should be intentional and varied.
Strategies such as wait time, pair sharing, collective pointing, and framing a safe space significantly improve audience engagement.
How a presenter responds to answers can be as important as the questions themselves.
Alan presented two sequencing strategies: (1) starting with direct information questions and moving toward synthesizing and open-ended, and (2) starting with open-ended or feeling questions and moving toward more specific ones.
Alan: Illustrated the first strategy with a spectroscopy example (hydrogen/helium gas tubes), moving from recall to synthesizing to open-ended.
Illustrated the second strategy with a UFO discussion example, though acknowledged the examples were not perfectly distinct in terms of categories.
Jeff: Noted that context determines whether a question is synthesizing or open-ended.
Alan: Emphasized that developing a rigid pattern is less important than being intentional about sequencing.
Conclusion
Thinking deliberately about question sequences improves program quality.
Homework suggested: design a question sequence for a program about a space colony, planetary craters, or a topic of the presenter's choice.
Alan suggested that presenters record their programs and analyze the questions asked. This prompted a lively discussion about the role of AI in self-analysis.
Alan: Recommended, if you have the equimpent and time, make an audio recording, list all questions, and reflect on whether the sequence of questions could be improved. Full transcript is not necessary—just list the questions.
Jeff: Pushed back on the idea that equipment is a barrier, noting that smartphones make recording easier than ever. He also suggested using AI to transcribe recordings and extract only the questions for focused analysis.
Todd: Argued that manually listening to one's own recording is more valuable than delegating analysis to AI, as the personal effort deepens self-awareness.
Jeff: Agreed there is a right and wrong way to use AI, and that using it to save time on transcription while still doing personal analysis is a valid approach.
Lesley: Added that listening to one's own audio captures tone of voice and audience reactions that AI cannot currently assess.
Alan: Referenced observing Japanese planetarium programs at an IPS conference in Osaka, noting their use of quiet, reflective pauses — a practice rarely seen in Western production shows.
Lesley: Connected this to research-backed practices in children's TV (e.g., Blue's Clues), where hosts pause after questions to give children time to respond.
Conclusion
Recording and reviewing one's own programs is a powerful tool for self-improvement.
AI can assist with transcription and question extraction, but personal listening remains essential for capturing tone and audience response.
Intentional silence and wait time are valuable and underused tools in planetarium presentations.
Alan discussed research-backed strategies for responding to audience contributions, emphasizing that how a presenter reacts shapes the safety and quality of participation throughout the program.
Alan: Cited research showing that waiting 4–6 seconds (vs. 1–2 seconds) before redirecting produces more complete, justified, and speculative answers.
Described three response types — Passive Acceptance (e.g., "mm-hmm," "okay," "that's a possibility"), Active Acceptance (rephrasing or summarizing the answer to show genuine listening), and Empathic (acknowledging feelings, e.g., "I understand why you're upset about money spent on space research").
Noted that tone of voice transforms even a neutral "okay" into something encouraging or dismissive.
Jeff: Emphasized always thanking respondents to signal that participation is valued and to encourage others to contribute later.
Conclusion
Early positive responses to audience answers set the tone for the entire program.
Active and empathic responses are more powerful than passive ones.
Wait time is a simple but highly effective technique that many presenters underuse.
Alan provided practical strategies for managing questions that seem unrelated or require lengthy answers.
Alan: Suggested giving short factual answers when that is all the person needs (e.g., "quarter of a million miles" for the distance to the moon, instead of digressing to explaining mean distance).
InvitE the person to hear a longer answer after the program if the question requires extensive explanation.
Admit when you do not know the answer; invite the audience to contribute — knowledgeable audience members can be a valuable resource.
Redirect self-answerable questions back to the questioner (e.g., "Look at your star map to find which direction Leo is in").
Say "We'll get to that later" when a question will be addressed later in the program.
Alan closed the workshop by inviting participants to reflect on the value of good questioning outside the planetarium context.
Alan: Used the example of a waiter asking "Would you like some water?" versus assuming, and "Are you ready for the check?" versus just placing it.
Todd: Humorously offered "Do you know how fast you were going?" as an example of a high-stakes question in daily life.
Lesley: Described family discussions about Christmas gifts as a positive example of open communication replacing guesswork.
Rosemary: Suggested asking "Would you like the short version or the long version?" before launching into a lengthy explanation.
Conclusion; Thoughtful questioning improves communication and relationships in all areas of life, not just in educational settings.
Alan wrapped up the session and outlined future plans for the workshop series.
Module 6, focused on designing audience participation activities, is planned for 2027 and has not yet been scheduled.
A recently published article in The Planetarian (June 2026, Vol 55 No. 2, page 52) covers the content of this workshop, and noted that the seminar series often invites authors of published articles to present live sessions.
Recordings, summaries, and sometimes slides are available on the website seminar archive (not only YouTube).
Rosemary invited attendees to suggest speakers or topics from conferences for future seminars.
...featuring Kate Troesch (Astro Society) on "Night Sky Network Connecting Communities" — second Friday of next month, 2 PM Pacific / 5 PM Eastern / 22 UTC.